Why You Should NOT Ditch Windows XP

Nathan Bauman over at PCWorld had an article titled Why You Should Ditch Your Windows XP Laptop Right Now. This sort of pitch has always interested me after a fashion – the thinking just escapes me (as a personal Windows user). The reasoning for a corporate environment would be different, of course.

Here are the reasons Nathan lists for switching to Windows 7:

  1. Windows 7 is easier to use.
  2. Windows 7 is more secure.
  3. Windows 7 supports disks with 4K blocks.
  4. Windows 7 supports more than 2Gb memory.
  5. Windows 8 is a disaster – so get Windows 7 before it goes away.

There are many reasons to stay with Windows XP for now. Be aware that I’ve not yet purchased my own Windows XP – I still have Windows 2000 for when I need Windows (which is almost never).

One reason is that Windows XP runs on virtually anything you can pick up – even one-year old and two-year old (gasp!) hardware. Requirements are 128Mb memory recommended and 1.5Gb disk on a Pentium at 233MHz or better. Windows 7 requires four times the memory, approximately 16 times the disk space, and four times the CPU power.

This variance in requirements leads to much lower costs for Windows XP hardware. A search on eBay for laptops with Windows XP shows a huge number of laptops for less than $300 – some as low as $120. These were laptops that presumably once sold for $1200 or $1800 or better. If we assume that a $300 laptop once sold for $1800, that is an 83% reduction in price from original retail – $1500 that stays in your pocket. New laptops with Windows 7 start at $350 or so for minimal systems; for a full-power system with Windows 7 it could be well over $1000.

The software itself is cheaper. Again, on eBay one can find Windows XP SP2 for $30-$40 whereas Windows 7 Ultimate is $75 and up – a savings of over %50.

Lastly, why buy Windows 7 now at retail prices when you can wait for Windows 8 – and get Windows 7 at fire-sale prices for hardware that by then will have lost 80% of its value. Just by waiting you can save thousands of dollars.

There is also the fact that a lot of software may not yet fully support Windows 7, and the software you count on the most may run only on Windows XP.

So now – that’s why you should stick with Windows XP (just remember to properly secure it!). Let everyone else spend their thousands of dollars and you can get their old equipment for a fraction of its original cost.

However, for an enterprise, the reasoning would be different – and the results might be different.