4 January 2012 5 Comments
Nathan Bauman over at PCWorld had an article titled Why You Should Ditch Your Windows XP Laptop Right Now. This sort of pitch has always interested me after a fashion – the thinking just escapes me (as a personal Windows user). The reasoning for a corporate environment would be different, of course.
Here are the reasons Nathan lists for switching to Windows 7:
- Windows 7 is easier to use.
- Windows 7 is more secure.
- Windows 7 supports disks with 4K blocks.
- Windows 7 supports more than 2Gb memory.
- Windows 8 is a disaster – so get Windows 7 before it goes away.
There are many reasons to stay with Windows XP for now. Be aware that I’ve not yet purchased my own Windows XP – I still have Windows 2000 for when I need Windows (which is almost never).
One reason is that Windows XP runs on virtually anything you can pick up – even one-year old and two-year old (gasp!) hardware. Requirements are 128Mb memory recommended and 1.5Gb disk on a Pentium at 233MHz or better. Windows 7 requires four times the memory, approximately 16 times the disk space, and four times the CPU power.
This variance in requirements leads to much lower costs for Windows XP hardware. A search on eBay for laptops with Windows XP shows a huge number of laptops for less than $300 – some as low as $120. These were laptops that presumably once sold for $1200 or $1800 or better. If we assume that a $300 laptop once sold for $1800, that is an 83% reduction in price from original retail – $1500 that stays in your pocket. New laptops with Windows 7 start at $350 or so for minimal systems; for a full-power system with Windows 7 it could be well over $1000.
The software itself is cheaper. Again, on eBay one can find Windows XP SP2 for $30-$40 whereas Windows 7 Ultimate is $75 and up – a savings of over %50.
Lastly, why buy Windows 7 now at retail prices when you can wait for Windows 8 – and get Windows 7 at fire-sale prices for hardware that by then will have lost 80% of its value. Just by waiting you can save thousands of dollars.
There is also the fact that a lot of software may not yet fully support Windows 7, and the software you count on the most may run only on Windows XP.
So now – that’s why you should stick with Windows XP (just remember to properly secure it!). Let everyone else spend their thousands of dollars and you can get their old equipment for a fraction of its original cost.
However, for an enterprise, the reasoning would be different – and the results might be different.